acted to stabilize the total number of Jewish youngsters, while probably producing a sharp drop in their average academic achievement. Thus, there appears to be no evidence for racial bias against Asians, even excluding the race-neutral impact of athletic recruitment, legacy admissions, and geographical diversity. Since Chuas husband is not Asian, she could obviously encourage her children to improve their admissions chances by concealing their ethnic identity during the application process; but this would surely represent an enormous personal humiliation for a proud and highly successful Illinois-born American of Chinese. Thus, the relative presence of Jews rose sharply while that of all other groups declined, and this occurred during exactly the period when the once-remarkable academic performance of Jewish high school students seemed to suddenly collapse. However, solid statistical data regarding this elite wasp subpopulation is almost non-existent, and anyway the boundaries of the category are quite imprecise and fluid across generations. 108 These articles included denunciations of Princetons long historical legacy of anti-Semitism and quickly led to official apologies, followed by an immediate 30 percent rebound in Jewish numbers. Indeed, Karabel opens the final chapter of his book by performing exactly this calculation and noting the extreme irony that the wasp demographic group which had once so completely dominated Americas elite universities and virtually all the major institutions of American life had by 2000. Meanwhile, an ethnic distribution much closer to this apparent ability-ratio is found at Caltech, whose admissions are purely meritocratic, unlike the completely opaque, subjective, and discretionary Ivy League system so effectively described by Karabel, Golden, and others. 30 By comparing the prevalence of these particular names on the California NMS semifinalist lists with the total size of the corresponding California ethnicities, we can estimate that California Vietnamese are significantly more likely than whites to score very highly on such tests, while Koreans.
Although the Asian Tiger Mom behavior described by author Amy Chua provoked widespread hostility and ridicule, consider the situation from her perspective. An Inner Ring and an Outer Ring But if selecting our future elites by purest diversity wouldnt work, and using purest meritocracy would seem an equally bad idea, what would be the right approach to take as a replacement for todays complex mixture of diversity. Espenshade and his colleagues, whose results were summarized in his 2009 book No Longer Separate, Not Yet Equal, co-authored with Alexandria Walton Radford.
The Ivy Experience was a tremendous asset to my daughter during her application to college. Their advice on how to prepare a winning essay, and how to deal with decisions to be made about early registration and a host of other topics were invaluable during this process.
Meanwhile, the national number of Jewish semifinalists comes out at less than 6 percent of the total based on direct inspection of the individual names, with estimates based on either the particularly distinctive names considered by Sailer or the full set of such highly distinctive. An examination of other available statistics seems to support my recollections and provides evidence for a dramatic recent decline in the academic performance of American Jews The.S. As mentioned earlier, over the last couple of decades widespread perceptions of racial bias in admissions have led a significant number of students to refuse to reveal their race, which the official statistics classify as race unknown. These figures seem extremely difficult to explain except as evidence of sharp racial bias. Since their strong academic performance is coupled with relatively little political power, they would be obvious candidates for discrimination in the harsh realpolitik of university admissions as documented by Karabel, and indeed he briefly raises the possibility of an anti-Asian admissions bias, before concluding that. So perhaps what had seemed like a clear pattern of anti-Asian discrimination is actually just the workings of academic meritocracy, at least when combined with a fixed allocation of diversity admissions. We should also consider that under such a selection system, any interest or involvement not directly contributing to the academic transcriptincluding activities associated with artistic talent, sports ability, or extra-curricular leadershipwould disappear from our top universities, since students who devoted any significant time to those. And Harvard Facebook fame might appear to be perfect examples of this social class, but their grandfather actually had an eighth-grade education and came from a long line of impoverished coalminers in rural Pennsylvania.
Studybay is an academic writing service for students: essays, term papers, dissertations and much more!
We re trusted and chosen by many students all over the world!
This is the foliage of destiny.
So, you want to go.